-Diurnal variation, PEFR >20%
-PEFR >15% improved, 200ml, beta agonist MDI 400mcg or neb 2.5mg or prednisolone 30mg/d for 2 w
-PEFR>15% worsened, 6min exercise or metacholine test
Thursday, August 15, 2013
Tuesday, August 13, 2013
Positive CSF VDRL, Negative Serum RPR, VDRL
I'm sending this article because of the two
recent unusual patients with positive CSF VDRL 1:1024 but negative serum
RPR (elderly lady has negative serum VDRL too).
Both have headache of 1-2 weeks duration as an indication for LP. One an elderly 60-year-old with concomitant salmonella sp sepsis, lymphadenopathy and scalp abscess. Another a young 14-year-old lady who presented with 1 week history of fever, headache and neck stiffness. The younger lady's CSF was all normal (normal protein, glucose, no cells, no crypt ag, only pressure>34, Normal MRI). Both have no STD risk factor and have negative HIV serology.
Question:
Can one has positive CSF VDRL (high titer) but negative serum RPR & serum VDRL?
Yes. As mentioned below, "Unfortunately, the nontreponemal tests (VDRL and RPR) may be nonreactive in late neurosyphilis, particularly in tabes dorsalis. When there is suspicion for late forms of neurosyphilis, serum treponemal tests (FTA-ABS, TPPA, or syphilis EIA) should always be performed"
Therefore, we must still do serum TPHA. If serum TPHA is negative, then we can probably conclude that the CSF VDRL test is an error since both patients cannot have neurosyphilis without first having syphilis. And I believe the younger lady cannot have late neurosysphilis (esp tabes dorsalis) because this condition takes 15-20 years to develop.
Appreciate your thought.
Thank you.
Regards,
HG
Neurosyphilis
Both have headache of 1-2 weeks duration as an indication for LP. One an elderly 60-year-old with concomitant salmonella sp sepsis, lymphadenopathy and scalp abscess. Another a young 14-year-old lady who presented with 1 week history of fever, headache and neck stiffness. The younger lady's CSF was all normal (normal protein, glucose, no cells, no crypt ag, only pressure>34, Normal MRI). Both have no STD risk factor and have negative HIV serology.
Question:
Can one has positive CSF VDRL (high titer) but negative serum RPR & serum VDRL?
Yes. As mentioned below, "Unfortunately, the nontreponemal tests (VDRL and RPR) may be nonreactive in late neurosyphilis, particularly in tabes dorsalis. When there is suspicion for late forms of neurosyphilis, serum treponemal tests (FTA-ABS, TPPA, or syphilis EIA) should always be performed"
Therefore, we must still do serum TPHA. If serum TPHA is negative, then we can probably conclude that the CSF VDRL test is an error since both patients cannot have neurosyphilis without first having syphilis. And I believe the younger lady cannot have late neurosysphilis (esp tabes dorsalis) because this condition takes 15-20 years to develop.
Appreciate your thought.
Thank you.
Regards,
HG
Neurosyphilis
Literature review current through:
Jul 2013.
|
This topic last updated:
Jun 19, 2013.
INTRODUCTION — The
term "neurosyphilis" refers to infection of the central nervous system
(CNS) by Treponema pallidum (T. pallidum), subspecies pallidum.
Neurosyphilis can occur at any time after initial infection.
Early
in the course of syphilis, the most common forms of neurosyphilis
involve the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), meninges, and vasculature
(asymptomatic meningitis, symptomatic meningitis, and meningovascular
disease). Late in disease, the most common forms involve the brain and
spinal cord parenchyma (general paralysis of the insane and tabes
dorsalis). Each form has characteristic clinical findings, but in some
cases there is overlap between these findings.
This topic will
review the pathogenesis, epidemiology, clinical findings, diagnosis, and
treatment of neurosyphilis. Other aspects of syphilis are discussed
separately. (See "Pathophysiology, transmission, and natural history of syphilis" and "Pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, and treatment of early syphilis" and "Pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, and treatment of late syphilis" and "Epidemiology, clinical presentation, and diagnosis of syphilis in the
HIV-infected patient".)
PATHOGENESIS — Neurosyphilis
begins with invasion of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), a process that
probably occurs shortly after acquisition of Treponema pallidum (T.
pallidum) infection. The organism can be identified in the CSF from
approximately one-quarter of untreated patients with early syphilis [1,2]. Although investigators in the first half of the 20th
century did not believe that there were "neurotropic strains" of T.
pallidum, a study conducted in the antibiotic era suggested that strain
variability may affect the characteristics of the infection [3].
Unlike
other bacteria that can infect the CSF, invasion of CSF with T.
pallidum does not always result in persistent infection, as spontaneous
resolution may occur in some cases without an inflammatory response. In
other cases, spontaneous resolution may occur after a transient
meningitis.
Persistent meningitis is the result of failure to
clear organisms from the CSF. Patients with persistent meningitis have
"asymptomatic neurosyphilis", and individuals with this form of
neurosyphilis are at risk for subsequent forms of symptomatic
neurosyphilis (figure 1) [4]. Studies performed in the early 20th
century showed that the more abnormal the CSF in asymptomatic
meningitis, the more likely that symptomatic neurosyphilis will develop [5].
The
mechanism of T. pallidum clearance from CSF is probably similar to the
immune response that occurs in peripheral infection, where opsonized
organisms are cleared by activated macrophages. Supporting evidence
comes from a study of nonhuman primates infected with T. pallidum; the
number of CSF CD4+ T cells and the amount of gamma-interferon produced
by CSF lymphocytes increased throughout the period of bacterial
clearance, consistent with a "Th-1-type" cellular immune response [6].
EPIDEMIOLOGY — Neurosyphilis was common in the pre-antibiotic era, occurring in 25 to 35 percent of patients with syphilis [4,7].
Of these, approximately one-third had asymptomatic neurosyphilis,
one-third had tabes dorsalis, and at least 10 percent had paresis.
Meningovascular syphilis was seen in about 10 percent, with the
remaining patients having other forms of neurosyphilis, including
symptomatic meningitis and cranial nerve abnormalities.
In the
current era, early neurosyphilis is more common than late neurosyphilis,
and is most frequently seen in patients with human immunodeficiency
virus (HIV) infection. This association may simply reflect the fact that
syphilis is most common in men who have sex with men, many of whom are
HIV-infected, or it may reflect a true difference in susceptibility [8]. (See "Epidemiology, clinical presentation, and diagnosis of syphilis in the HIV-infected patient".)
HIV-infected
persons with lower peripheral CD4+ T cell counts are more likely to
have symptomatic neurosyphilis than those with higher CD4+ T cell counts
[9].
The
frequency of the late forms of neurosyphilis (general paresis and tabes
dorsalis) has declined in the antibiotic era, with the result that
these forms, particularly tabes dorsalis, are now uncommon [10].
Many experts believe that this decline is due, at least in part, to the
widespread use of antibiotics for unrelated illnesses.
CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS — Neurosyphilis can be classified into early forms and late forms (figure 1).
The early forms typically affect the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF),
meninges, and vasculature, while the late forms affect the brain and
spinal cord parenchyma. Most of what we know about the clinical
manifestations of neurosyphilis comes from observations made before the
advent of penicillin [4,7].
Early neurosyphilis
Asymptomatic neurosyphilis — By
definition, patients with asymptomatic neurosyphilis have no symptoms
or signs of central nervous system (CNS) disease, although they may have
evidence of concomitant primary or secondary syphilis. Asymptomatic
neurosyphilis can occur within weeks to months after infection, but less
commonly occurs more than two years after infection.
The
diagnosis is based on the identification of CSF abnormalities, including
a lymphocytic pleocytosis that is typically <100 cells/microL, an elevated protein concentration that is usually <100 mg/dL, a reactive CSF-Venereal Disease Research Laboratory (VDRL), or a combination of these abnormalities.
In patients with suspected asymptomatic neurosyphilis who do not have HIV infection, a CSF lymphocyte count >5 cells/microL or a protein concentration >45 mg/dL
is consistent with the diagnosis of neurosyphilis. Establishing the
diagnosis of asymptomatic neurosyphilis in patients who have HIV
infection with CSF pleocytosis but nonreactive CSF-VDRL is difficult
because mild CSF pleocytosis and elevated protein can be due to HIV
itself. (See 'Diagnosis' below.)
Patients
with asymptomatic neurosyphilis, regardless of CSF-VDRL reactivity,
should be treated for neurosyphilis to prevent progression to
symptomatic disease. (See 'Treatment' below.)
Symptomatic meningitis — Most
often, symptomatic meningitis occurs within the first year after
infection, but it can occur years later. As with asymptomatic
neurosyphilis, peripheral findings of early syphilis may coexist,
particularly the rash of secondary disease.
Patients with
symptomatic syphilitic meningitis complain of headache, confusion,
nausea and vomiting, and stiff neck. Visual acuity may be impaired if
there is concomitant uveitis, vitritis, retinitis, or optic neuritis.
Signs include cranial neuropathies, particularly of the optic, facial,
or auditory nerves. (See 'Ocular syphilis' below and 'Otosyphilis' below.)
Meningitis
may cause hydrocephalus as well as arteritis of small-, medium-, or
large-sized vessels, leading to ischemia or infarction of brain or
spinal cord. (See 'Meningovascular syphilis' below.)
Focal
meningeal inflammation may lead to diffuse leptomeningitis or to
syphilitic gummas, which are focal areas of inflammation that present as
mass lesions contiguous with the leptomeninges (image 1). Meningitis, brain ischemia, or gummas may cause seizures.
Syphilitic
meningitis may uncommonly affect the spinal cord and cause
meningomyelitis or hyperplastic pachymeningitis with polyradiculopathy.
Symptoms and signs include back pain, sensory loss, incontinence, leg
weakness, or muscle atrophy.
The CSF abnormalities that accompany
symptomatic meningitis are more severe than those seen in asymptomatic
meningitis. CSF lymphocyte counts are generally between 200 to 400 cells/microL, CSF protein concentration is typically between 100 to 200 mg/dL,
and CSF-VDRL is almost always reactive. Neuroimaging may show
enhancement of meninges, spinal fluid, cranial nerves, or spinal roots.
Cerebral gummas show focal areas of enhancement adjacent to the
meninges, often with a "dural tail", and surrounding edema (image 1).
Ocular syphilis — Ocular
syphilis can involve almost any eye structure, but posterior uveitis is
most common and presents with diminished visual acuity [11,12].
Additional manifestations may include optic neuropathy, interstitial
keratitis, anterior and intermediate uveitis, chorioretinitis, and
retinal vasculitis. Ocular syphilis is often, but not always,
accompanied by syphilitic meningitis.
Otosyphilis — Hearing loss, with or without tinnitus, should be considered as part of the neurologic symptoms or signs of neurosyphilis [13]. Like ocular syphilis, hearing loss may or may not be accompanied by meningitis.
Meningovascular syphilis — As
with other bacterial meningitides, syphilitic meningitis can cause an
infectious arteritis that may affect any vessel in the subarachnoid
space surrounding the brain or spinal cord and result in thrombosis,
ischemia, and infarction. This form of neurosyphilis may present as an
ischemic stroke in a young person. Stroke may develop at any time from
the first months to the first few years after infection, with an average
interval of seven years in a series conducted in the pre-antibiotic era
[4].
Many
patients with meningovascular syphilis have prodromal symptoms, such as
headache, dizziness, or personality changes, for days or weeks before
the onset of ischemia or stroke. These symptoms are probably due to
concomitant meningitis.
The manifestations of cerebral ischemia
may be acute or chronic. The clinical findings with stroke reflect the
territory of the vessel involved. The middle cerebral artery and its
branches are most commonly affected. Less commonly, meningovascular
disease affects the anterior spinal artery and thereby causes spinal
cord infarction.
The CSF abnormalities associated with
meningovascular neurosyphilis are generally less severe than in those of
acute meningitis, with lymphocytic pleocytosis between 10 to 100 cells/microL and protein concentration of 100 to 200 mg/dL. As with all of the early symptomatic forms of neurosyphilis, CSF-VDRL is usually but not always reactive.
Angiography
(performed with computed tomographic, magnetic resonance, or
conventional catheter techniques) may demonstrate either focal segmental
arterial narrowing, focal narrowing and dilatation, or total occlusion,
similar to the findings seen in other infectious or noninfectious
vasculitides. Neuroimaging shows one or more areas of infarction.
Late neurosyphilis — General
paresis and tabes dorsalis are considered "tertiary" forms of
neurosyphilis, while the early forms of neurosyphilis are not.
General paresis — General
paresis (also known as general paralysis of the insane, paretic
neurosyphilis, or dementia paralytica) is a progressive dementing
illness. In the pre-penicillin era, general paresis resulted in death
within an average of 2.5 years [4].
General paresis usually develops 10 to 25 years after infection, but it
can occur as early as two years after infection. In the first half of
the 20th century, this form of neurosyphilis accounted for about 10 percent of all admissions to psychiatric hospitals.
In
the early stage of disease, general paresis is associated with symptoms
of forgetfulness and personality change. Most affected individuals
experience progression of deficits in memory and judgment leading to
severe dementia. Less often, patients may develop psychiatric symptoms
such as depression, mania, or psychosis.
While the neurologic
examination may be normal in some patients with general paresis, common
abnormal findings include dysarthria, facial and limb hypotonia,
intention tremors of the face, tongue, and hands, and reflex
abnormalities. Pupillary abnormalities, including Argyll-Robertson
pupils, may also be seen. However, pupillary findings are more typical
of tabes dorsalis. (See 'Tabes dorsalis' below.)
CSF abnormalities are the rule in paretic neurosyphilis, with elevated lymphocytes of 25 to 75 cells/microL and a protein concentration in the range of 50 to 100 mg/dL. The CSF-VDRL is reactive in virtually all patients, although rare cases with a nonreactive CSF serology have been reported [14]. Neuroimaging most commonly shows atrophy.
Tabes dorsalis — Tabes
dorsalis (also called locomotor ataxia) is a disease of the posterior
columns of the spinal cord and of the dorsal roots. It has the longest
latent period between primary infection and onset of symptoms of all
forms of neurosyphilis, with the interval averaging about 20 years, but
sometimes as few as three years.
While tabes dorsalis was the most
common form of neurosyphilis in the pre-antibiotic era, it is uncommon
in the antibiotic era. (See 'Epidemiology' above.)
The
most frequent symptoms of tabes dorsalis are sensory ataxia and
lancinating pains. The latter are characterized by sudden, brief, severe
stabs of pain that may affect the limbs, back, or face and that may
last for minutes or days. Less common symptoms are paresthesias and
gastric crises, characterized by recurrent attacks of severe epigastric
pain, nausea, and vomiting.
Pupillary irregularities are among the
most common signs with tabes dorsalis, and the Argyll-Robertson pupil
accounts for approximately one-half of these. An Argyll-Robertson pupil
is small, does not respond to light, contracts normally to accommodation
and convergence, dilates imperfectly to mydriatics, and does not dilate
in response to painful stimuli. (See "Tonic pupil", section on 'Differential diagnosis'.)
Other
findings seen with tabes dorsalis include absent lower extremity
reflexes, impaired vibratory and position sensation, and, less commonly,
impaired touch and pain, sensory ataxia, and optic atrophy.
The CSF may be completely normal in tabes dorsalis, or may show a mild lymphocytic pleocytosis with 10 to 50 cells/microL and protein concentrations of 45 to 75 mg/dL. In this form of neurosyphilis, as many as one-quarter of the CSF-VDRL tests are nonreactive.
Atypical neurosyphilis — Some
studies from the antibiotic era have reported "atypical" forms of
neurosyphilis, a term that is used to describe neurosyphilis that does
not fulfill the clinical criteria for one of the "classic" forms (eg,
symptomatic meningitis, meningovascular syphilis, general paresis, and
tabes dorsalis). As an example, a study from the early 1970s of 289
patients with reactive serum CSF-FTA-ABS tests reported that
neurosyphilis was diagnosed in 241 (84 percent) based on the
identification of reflex, sensory, or pupillary changes, or seizures [15]. However, similar cases of neurosyphilis were described in the 1940s [4]. Thus, it is likely that such "atypical" forms of neurosyphilis have always existed.
That said, several modern case reports have described patients with neurosyphilis that mimicked herpes encephalitis [16].
These patients generally had acute onset of cognitive changes, although
some patients had more slowly progressive presentations. Virtually all
had seizures. Brain MRI showed unilateral or bilateral medial temporal
lobe lesions characterized by high signal on T2 and fluid-attenuated
inversion recovery (FLAIR) sequences, and these temporal lobe changes
resolved after treatment for neurosyphilis [16].
In addition to mesiotemporal lobe lesions, other reports have observed
MRI signal abnormalities in parietal, temporo-occipital, and thalamic
regions [17].
It
is difficult to categorize these cases into one of the classic clinical
descriptions of neurosyphilis described above (eg, symptomatic
meningitis, meningovascular syphilis, general paresis, tabes dorsalis).
While patients with a more slowly progressive course could be considered
to have general paresis, those with acute onset and temporal lobe
imaging abnormalities present a greater challenge for classification.
The features of these cases are most similar to meningovascular
syphilis, except that the temporal lobe abnormalities do not respect
vascular territories. Thus, it is probably best to describe them as an
overlap between meningeal and parenchymal disease, rather than attribute
them to one of the classic clinical forms of neurosyphilis. The fact
that seizures themselves may cause reversible temporal lobe
abnormalities further complicates categorization of these cases [18].
DIAGNOSIS — In
his 1944 text, Stokes wrote, "The frequency of neurosyphilis in general
medical practice depends to a large extent on the thoroughness of the
search for signs of neuraxis involvement and the frequency with which
the spinal fluid examination is employed" [7]. This axiom remains true today.
Clinical suspicion and spinal fluid examination are keys to the diagnosis of neurosyphilis (algorithm 1 and algorithm 2).
- Lumbar puncture should be considered in the evaluation of a patient who presents with neurologic or ocular disease that could be caused by syphilis, but with unknown syphilis history.
- Lumbar puncture should be performed in the evaluation of a patient with known history of syphilis who presents with neurologic or ocular disease that could be caused by syphilis.
- Lumbar puncture should be considered in all patients with HIV infection and syphilis of any stage, even in the absence of neurologic or ocular disease (algorithm 2).
Unknown syphilis history — In
the setting of an unknown syphilis history, the first step in
establishing the diagnosis of neurosyphilis is confirming that the
patient has been infected with Treponema pallidum (T. pallidum), as a
patient cannot have neurosyphilis without first having syphilis.
Tests for syphilis include the following:
- Serum nontreponemal tests
- Venereal disease research laboratory (VDRL)
- Rapid plasma reagin (RPR)
- Serum treponemal tests
- Fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption (FTA-ABS)
- Treponema pallidum particle agglutination assay (TPPA)
- Syphilis enzyme immunoassay (EIA)
Confirmation
is straightforward when serum nontreponemal tests and treponemal tests
are reactive, as they virtually always are in early neurosyphilis. (See "Diagnostic testing for syphilis".)
Unfortunately,
the nontreponemal tests (VDRL and RPR) may be nonreactive in late
neurosyphilis, particularly in tabes dorsalis. When there is suspicion
for late forms of neurosyphilis, serum treponemal tests (FTA-ABS, TPPA,
or syphilis EIA) should always be performed. These tests remain reactive
for life in virtually all individuals regardless of previous treatment.
Reactivity of these serum tests confirms that the patient has had
syphilis at some time, and that he or she is at risk for neurosyphilis.
Patients with nonreactive serum treponemal tests do not merit further evaluation for late neurosyphilis. (See "Diagnostic testing for syphilis".)
Known syphilis — In
patients with known syphilis, a lumbar puncture with cerebrospinal
fluid (CSF) examination should be performed in certain clinical
situations to evaluate the possibility of symptomatic or asymptomatic
neurosyphilis (algorithm 1 and algorithm 2).
The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
recommendations are that CSF examination should be performed in any of
the following situations [19]:
- Neurologic or ophthalmic signs or symptoms in any stage of syphilis.
- Evidence of active tertiary syphilis affecting other parts of the body. (See "Pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, and treatment of early syphilis", section on 'Latent syphilis'.)
- Treatment failure (including failure of serum nontreponemal tests to fall appropriately) in any stage of syphilis.
- Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection with late latent syphilis or syphilis of unknown duration.
A few caveats should be noted:
- Patients who have ocular syphilis or otosyphilis, with or without CSF abnormalities, should receive standard neurosyphilis treatment. The value of lumbar puncture is that if CSF abnormalities are identified, they can be followed to assess efficacy of treatment. (See 'Treatment' below.)
- Some experts recommend LP in all patients with concomitant HIV infection and syphilis, regardless of stage, because of reports of neurosyphilis (asymptomatic and symptomatic) occurring after standard treatment for early syphilis. (See "Epidemiology, clinical presentation, and diagnosis of syphilis in the HIV-infected patient".)
- Patients who have a serum RPR titer ≥1:32, with or without HIV infection, have an increased likelihood of a reactive CSF-VDRL. Available data suggest that the risk is increased approximately 11-fold in those without HIV infection and sixfold in those with HIV infection [20], regardless of syphilis stage or prior syphilis treatment [21]. In addition, in patients with HIV infection, a peripheral blood CD4 count of ≤350 cells/microL conveys an approximately three-fold increased risk of asymptomatic neurosyphilis [20,22]. Compared with the stage-based criteria for lumbar puncture recommended by the CDC for patients with concurrent HIV infection and syphilis, a retrospective analysis reported that performing lumbar puncture in patients with a serum RPR titer ≥1:32 or CD4 count <350 cells/microL resulted in fewer missed cases of asymptomatic neurosyphilis [23].
Given
these data, we suggest lumbar puncture for the diagnosis of
neurosyphilis in asymptomatic or symptomatic patients with a serum RPR
titer ≥1:32 and/or the presence of HIV infection with a CD4 count ≤350 cells/mm3.
Spinal fluid examination — While
a reactive CSF-VDRL establishes the diagnosis of neurosyphilis, a
nonreactive rest does not exclude the diagnosis. The CSF-VDRL test may
be falsely negative in as many as 70 percent of patients with
neurosyphilis. Furthermore, the CSF-VDRL test may be falsely positive
when the CSF is visibly blood-tinged and the serum nontreponemal test
titer is high.
In contrast to the CSF-VDRL, the CSF FTA-ABS test
is sensitive but not specific, particularly in asymptomatic
neurosyphilis. In the setting of lymphocytic CSF pleocytosis and a
nonreactive CSF-VDRL, a nonreactive CSF-FTA-ABS test excludes the
diagnosis of neurosyphilis in most instances [24].
Elevation
of the CSF protein concentration is consistent with neurosyphilis.
However, it may be less specific than CSF pleocytosis [25,26].
- In patients with suspected neurosyphilis who do not have HIV infection and who have nonreactive CSF-VDRL, a CSF lymphocyte count >5 cells/microL or a protein concentration >45 mg/dL is consistent with the diagnosis of neurosyphilis (algorithm 1). Results of the CSF-FTA-ABS test may be helpful in establishing or refuting the diagnosis of neurosyphilis when protein elevation is the sole CSF abnormality.
- In patients who have HIV infection and syphilis, establishing a diagnosis of neurosyphilis is particularly difficult when the CSF-VDRL is nonreactive in the setting of a mild CSF pleocytosis. The difficulty arises because HIV itself causes mild CSF pleocytosis and mild elevation of the CSF protein concentration. As noted earlier, in patients with neurosyphilis who are seronegative for HIV infection, the CSF leukocyte count is usually elevated to >5 cells/microL. This contrasts with patients who have HIV coinfection, where a CSF leukocyte count of >20 cells/microL is considered to be consistent with neurosyphilis.
One study found that an HIV-induced CSF pleocytosis was independently and significantly associated with three factors [27]:
- Lack of current antiretroviral use (OR 5.9, 95% CI 1.8-18.6)
- CD4 count >200/microL (OR 23.4, 95% CI 3.1-177.3)
- Detectable plasma HIV RNA (OR 3.3, 95% CI 1.1-9.4)
In HIV-infected patients who are taking antiretroviral agents, have CD4 counts ≤200 cells/microL,
or have an undetectable plasma HIV RNA viral load, the likelihood of an
HIV-induced CSF pleocytosis appears to be reduced by 70 to 96 percent [27]. Thus, a CSF pleocytosis in such patients who have syphilis is more likely to be due to neurosyphilis than to HIV.
TREATMENT — The treatment of neurosyphilis is discussed separately and reviewed here briefly. (See "Pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, and treatment of late syphilis", section on 'Neurosyphilis'.)
The
standard regimens recommended by current Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention (CDC) guidelines for the treatment of neurosyphilis,
including ocular syphilis, are as follows (table 1) [19]:
- Aqueous crystalline penicillin G (18 to 24 million units per day, administered as 3 to 4 million units IV every four hours, or 24 million units daily as a continuous infusion) for 10 to 14 days, or
- Procaine penicillin G (2.4 million units IM once daily) plus probenecid (500 mg orally four times a day) for 10 to 14 days
These regimens can also be used following desensitization to beta-lactams for patients who have a serious penicillin allergy [19]. Desensitization should be managed in consultation with a specialist.
An alternative treatment for patients who have a mild penicillin allergy is ceftriaxone (2 gm IV daily) for 10 to 14 days, with
careful observation for cross-reactivity [19].
No
controlled trials have evaluated the efficacy of the currently used
forms of penicillin for neurosyphilis treatment. Thus, recommendations
for treatment are based on clinical experience and on predicted
penetration of penicillin into the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and central
nervous system (CNS). Over the years, successively higher doses of
intravenous (IV) aqueous penicillin G have been recommended as first-line therapy for neurosyphilis (table 1) [19].
Limited data suggest that ceftriaxone or high-dose doxycycline could be used as alternatives to IV penicillin in patients with neurosyphilis [28,29].
Ocular
syphilis and otosyphilis are treated with the same regimen as is used
for neurosyphilis, regardless of the presence or absence of CSF
abnormalities. Treatment with topical glucocorticoids for ocular
syphilis and oral glucocorticoids for otosyphilis is often used in
conjunction with antibiotics.
Monitoring — Because
Treponema pallidum (T. pallidum) cannot be grown in the laboratory,
there is no microbiological test of cure. Thus, the success of
neurosyphilis therapy is judged by resolution or stabilization of
clinical abnormalities and by normalization of CSF abnormalities.
Neurologic
examination and lumbar puncture should be performed at three to six
months after treatment and every six months thereafter until the CSF
white blood cell count is normal and the CSF-Venereal Disease Research
Laboratory (VDRL) is nonreactive. The CSF white blood cell count should
decline at six months after successful treatment, and all CSF
abnormalities should resolve by two years after treatment. Failure to
meet these criteria should prompt retreatment. Retreatment is also
indicated if any follow-up CSF sample shows an increase in CSF white
blood cell count, or a fourfold increase in CSF-VDRL titer. CSF
abnormalities may normalize more slowly in patients who have human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection compared with those who are not
infected with HIV [25].
Normalization
of serum rapid plasma reagin (RPR) titer may predict successful
neurosyphilis treatment. Supporting evidence comes from a longitudinal
study of 110 patients with neurosyphilis, most with HIV coinfection, who
were treated for neurosyphilis [26].
At four, seven, and 13 months after treatment, normalization of the
serum RPR test, defined as a fourfold or greater decline in RPR titer or
reversion to nonreactive, predicted normalization of CSF white blood
cell count and CSF-VDRL reactivity in >90 percent of patients [26].
However, the predictive value of serum RPR normalization was lower for
HIV-infected patients who were not taking antiretroviral agents.
SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Epidemiology and clinical manifestations
- Neurosyphilis refers to infection of the central nervous system (CNS) by Treponema pallidum. This disorder begins with invasion of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), a process that probably occurs shortly after acquisition of T. pallidum infection. (See 'Pathogenesis' above.)
- Early in the course of syphilis, the most common forms of neurosyphilis involve the CSF, meninges, and vasculature (asymptomatic meningitis, symptomatic meningitis, and meningovascular disease). Late in disease, the most common forms involve the brain and spinal cord parenchyma (general paresis and tabes dorsalis) (figure 1). In the current era, early neurosyphilis is more common than late neurosyphilis, and is most frequently seen in patients with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. (See 'Epidemiology' above and 'Clinical manifestations' above.)
- Asymptomatic neurosyphilis lacks symptoms or signs of CNS disease, although there may be concomitant evidence of primary or secondary syphilis. Treatment of asymptomatic neurosyphilis prevents progression to the symptomatic forms. (See 'Asymptomatic neurosyphilis' above.)
- Symptomatic syphilitic meningitis is typically manifested by headache, confusion, nausea and vomiting, and stiff neck. Visual acuity may be impaired if there is concomitant uveitis, vitritis, retinitis, or optic neuritis. Signs include cranial neuropathies. (See 'Symptomatic meningitis' above.)
- Syphilitic meningitis can cause an infectious arteritis that may affect any vessel in the subarachnoid space and result in thrombosis, ischemia, and stroke involving the brain or spinal cord. (See 'Meningovascular syphilis' above.)
- The late forms of neurosyphilis (general paresis and tabes dorsalis) are the "tertiary" forms, while the early forms of neurosyphilis are not.
- General paresis is a progressive dementing illness that usually develops 10 to 25 years after infection. Symptoms of forgetfulness and personality change predominate early on, but progression leads to severe dementia. Common signs include dysarthria, facial and limb hypotonia, intention tremors of the face, tongue, and hands, and reflex abnormalities. (See 'General paresis' above.)
- Tabes dorsalis, uncommon in the modern era, is a disease of the posterior columns of the spinal cord and of the dorsal roots. The latent period between primary infection and onset of symptoms averages about 20 years. The most frequent manifestations include ataxia, lancinating pains, and pupillary irregularities. (See 'Tabes dorsalis' above.)
Diagnosis summary
- Clinical suspicion and spinal fluid examination are keys to the diagnosis of neurosyphilis. In the setting of unknown syphilis history, the first step is confirming current or previous infection with T. pallidum (algorithm 1 and algorithm 2). Serum nontreponemal tests (Venereal Disease Research Laboratory [VDRL] and RPR) and serum treponemal tests (fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption [FTA-ABS], treponema pallidum particle agglutination assay [TPPA], or syphilis enzyme immunoassay [EIA]) are virtually always reactive in early neurosyphilis. However, the nontreponemal tests may be nonreactive in late neurosyphilis, while the treponemal tests remain reactive. Therefore, serum treponemal tests (FTA-ABS, TPPA, or syphilis EIA) should always be performed when there is suspicion for late forms of neurosyphilis. (See 'Diagnosis' above.)
- In a patient with known syphilis, we recommend lumbar puncture with CSF examination for those who have neurologic or ocular signs or symptoms, active tertiary syphilis affecting other parts of the body, or treatment failure in any stage of syphilis. In addition, we suggest lumbar puncture for all asymptomatic or symptomatic patients with a serum RPR titer ≥1:32 or the presence of HIV infection with a CD4 count ≤350 cells/mm3. (See 'Known syphilis' above.)
- The CSF-VDRL is specific but not sensitive for the diagnosis of neurosyphilis. In contrast, the CSF FTA-ABS test is sensitive but not specific, particularly in asymptomatic neurosyphilis. Establishing a diagnosis of neurosyphilis is difficult when the CSF-VDRL is nonreactive in patients with concurrent HIV infection and syphilis who have a mild CSF pleocytosis, because HIV itself can cause a mild CSF pleocytosis and elevation of the CSF protein concentration. (See 'Spinal fluid examination' above.)
Treatment summary
- For patients with neurosyphilis who are not penicillin-allergic, we recommend treatment with penicillin (Grade 1B). The standard regimens recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) are listed above and shown in the table (table 1). Patients who have a serious penicillin allergy must first undergo desensitization to beta-lactams prior to penicillin therapy. For patients who have a mild penicillin allergy, we suggest ceftriaxone (2 gm IV daily) for 10 to 14 days with careful observation for cross-reactivity (Grade 2C). For patients with serious penicillin allergies who refuse desensitization or those who cannot be treated with penicillin and ceftriaxone, an alternative is oral doxycycline (200 mg twice daily) for 21 to 28 days. (See 'Treatment' above.)
- Lumbar puncture should be performed three to six months after treatment and every six months thereafter until the CSF white blood cell count is normal and the CSF-VDRL is nonreactive. We suggest retreatment if these criteria are not met by two years after treatment. In addition, we suggest retreatment if there is an increase in the CSF white blood cell count, or a fourfold increase in CSF-VDRL titer, in any follow-up CSF sample. (See 'Monitoring' above.)
- In immunocompetent patients or HIV-infected patients who are taking antiretroviral agents and in whom a follow-up lumbar puncture cannot be performed, normalization of the serum RPR titer can be used as a surrogate for success of neurosyphilis treatment. (See 'Monitoring' above.)
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)